[Research progress in targeted delivery of inner ear using nanocarriers].

Various inner ear diseases such as sensorineural deafness and Meniere's disease bring about problems such as speech communication disorders and decreased work efficiency, which seriously affect the life quality of patients. Due to the special anatomical structure and blood-labyrinth barrier in the inner ear, the current drug administration methods are often unable to achieve satisfactory results. Nanocarriers are the forefront and hot spot of nanotechnology research. In recent years, a lot of research progress has been made in the field of targeted delivery of the inner ear, which is expected to be eventually applied to the treatment of clinical diseases of the inner ear. This review focuses on the advantages, main research achievements and limitations of various nanocarriers in the targeted delivery of the inner ear, hoping to provide new ideas for related research.

[Endothelial dysfunction as a pathogenetic factor of sensorineural hearing loss]. / Endotelial'naya disfunktsiya kak patogeneticheskii faktor sensonevral'noi tugoukhosti.

Chronic sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is a common disease that leads to disability of the population. Despite the many reports devoted to SNHL, the question of the pathogenesis of the disease is still open. Many researchers consider the development of SNHL as a manifestation of microangiopathy. The mechanism of development of microangiopathy in SNHL is multifactorial, but most researchers agree that endothelial dysfunction (ED) triggers a complex of pathological changes in the vessels of the inner ear. OBJECTIVE: Review of the results of scientific research in recent years on the problem of etiopathogenesis of sensorineural hearing loss from the perspective of endothelial dysfunction in the formation of auditory disorders.

Guinea Pig Round Window Membrane Explantation for Ex Vivo Studies.

Efficient and minimally invasive drug delivery to the inner ear is a significant challenge. The round window membrane (RWM), being one of the few entry points to the inner ear, has become a vital focus of investigation. However, due to the complexities of isolating the RWM, our understanding of its pharmacokinetics remains limited. The RWM comprises three distinct layers: the outer epithelium, the middle connective tissue layer, and the inner epithelial layer, each potentially possessing unique delivery properties. Current models for investigating transport across the RWM utilize in vivo animal models or ex vivo RWM models which rely on cell cultures or membrane fragments. Guinea pigs serve as a validated preclinical model for the investigation of drug pharmacokinetics within the inner ear and are an important animal model for the translational development of delivery vehicles to the cochlea. In this study, we describe an approach for explantation of a guinea pig RWM with surrounding cochlear bone for benchtop drug delivery experiments. This method allows for preservation of native RWM architecture and may provide a more realistic representation of barriers to transport than current benchtop models.

A silk-based hydrogel containing dexamethasone and lipoic acid microcrystals for local delivery to the inner ear.

Local drug delivery has been exploited recently to treat hearing loss, as this method can both bypass the blood-labyrinth barrier and provide sustained drug release. Combined drug microcrystals (MCs) offer additional advantages for sensorineural hearing loss treatment via intratympanic (IT) injection due to their shape effect and combination strategy. In this study, to endow viscous effects of hydrogels, nonspherical dexamethasone (DEX) and lipoic acid (LA) MCs were incorporated into silk fibroin (SF) hydrogels, which were subsequently administered to the tympanic cavity to investigate their pharmaceutical properties. First, we prepared DEX and LA MCs by a traditional precipitation technique followed by SF hydrogel incorporation (SF+DEX+LA). After characterization of the physicochemical features, including morphology, rheology, and dissolution, both a suspension of combined DEX and LA MCs (DEX+LA) and SF+DEX+LA were administered to guinea pigs by IT injection, after which the pharmacokinetics, biodegradation and biocompatibility were evaluated. To our surprise, compared to the DEX+LA group, the pharmacokinetics of the SF+DEX+LA hydrogel group did not improve significantly, which may be ascribed to their nonspherical shape and deposition effects of the drugs MCs. The cochlear tissue in each group displayed good morphology, with no obvious inflammatory reactions. This combined MC suspension has the clear advantages of no vehicle, easy scale-up preparation, and good biocompatibility and outcomes, which paves the way for practical treatment of hearing loss via local drug delivery.

Probucol-bile acid based nanoparticles protect auditory cells from oxidative stress: an in vitro study.

Aim: Excessive free radicals contribute to oxidative stress and mitochondrial dysfunction in sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL). The antioxidant probucol holds promise, but its limited bioavailability and inner ear barriers hinder effective SNHL treatment. Methodology: We addressed this by developing probucol-loaded nanoparticles with polymers and lithocholic acid and tested them on House Ear Institute-Organ of Corti cells. Results: Probucol-based nanoparticles effectively reduced oxidative stress-induced apoptosis, enhanced cellular viability, improved probucol uptake and promoted mitochondrial function. Additionally, they demonstrated the capacity to reduce reactive oxygen species through the nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor 2/heme oxygenase-1 pathway. Conclusion: This innovative nanoparticle system holds the potential to prevent oxidative stress-related hearing impairment, providing an effective solution for SNHL.

Hearing loss affects millions of people worldwide, and its prevalence is expected to double by 2050. Current treatments have limitations, pushing researchers to explore new options. Oxidative stress is a key player in hearing loss and is known to damage inner ear hair cells. While antioxidants, known for their protective effects, hold promise, delivering them effectively to the inner ear is challenging. Scientists have been testing nanoparticles loaded with the antioxidant probucol to fight hearing loss. In this study, these particles protected inner ear cells in cell studies, offering potential hope for preventing hearing problems. This research is a significant step toward finding better treatments for hearing loss.

Age-related changes in the zebrafish and killifish inner ear and lateral line.

Age-related hearing loss (ARHL) is a debilitating disorder for millions worldwide. While there are multiple underlying causes of ARHL, one common factor is loss of sensory hair cells. In mammals, new hair cells are not produced postnatally and do not regenerate after damage, leading to permanent hearing impairment. By contrast, fish produce hair cells throughout life and robustly regenerate these cells after toxic insult. Despite these regenerative abilities, zebrafish show features of ARHL. Here, we show that aged zebrafish of both sexes exhibited significant hair cell loss and decreased cell proliferation in all inner ear epithelia (saccule, lagena, utricle). Ears from aged zebrafish had increased expression of pro-inflammatory genes and significantly more macrophages than ears from young adult animals. Aged zebrafish also had fewer lateral line hair cells and less cell proliferation than young animals, although lateral line hair cells still robustly regenerated following damage. Unlike zebrafish, African turquoise killifish (an emerging aging model) only showed hair cell loss in the saccule of aged males, but both sexes exhibit age-related changes in the lateral line. Our work demonstrates that zebrafish exhibit key features of auditory aging, including hair cell loss and increased inflammation. Further, our finding that aged zebrafish have fewer lateral line hair cells yet retain regenerative capacity, suggests a decoupling of homeostatic hair cell addition from regeneration following acute trauma. Finally, zebrafish and killifish show species-specific strategies for lateral line homeostasis that may inform further comparative research on aging in mechanosensory systems.

A Low Dose of Rapamycin Promotes Hair Cell Differentiation by Enriching SOX2+ Progenitors in the Neonatal Mouse Inner Ear Organoids.

PURPOSE: To investigate the impact of rapamycin on the differentiation of hair cells. METHODS: Murine cochlear organoids were derived from cochlear progenitor cells. Different concentrations of rapamycin were added into the culture medium at different proliferation and differentiation stages. RESULTS: Rapamycin exhibited a concentration-dependent reduction in the proliferation of these inner ear organoids. Nevertheless, organoids subjected to a 10-nM dose of rapamycin demonstrated a markedly increased proportion of hair cells. Furthermore, rapamycin significantly upregulated the expression of markers associated with both hair cells and supporting cells, including ATOH1, MYO7A, and SOX2. Mechanistic studies revealed that rapamycin preferentially suppressed cells without Sox2 expression during the initial proliferation stage, thereby augmenting and refining the population of SOX2+ progenitors. These enriched progenitors were predisposed to differentiate into hair cells during the later stages of organoid development. Conversely, the use of the mTOR activator MHY 1485 demonstrated opposing effects. CONCLUSION: Our findings underscore a practical strategy for enhancing the generation of inner ear organoids with a low dose of rapamycin, achieved by enriching SOX2+ progenitors in an in vitro setting.

Genetically modified pigs: Emerging animal models for hereditary hearing loss.

Hereditary hearing loss (HHL), a genetic disorder that impairs auditory function, significantly affects quality of life and incurs substantial economic losses for society. To investigate the underlying causes of HHL and evaluate therapeutic outcomes, appropriate animal models are necessary. Pigs have been extensively used as valuable large animal models in biomedical research. In this review, we highlight the advantages of pig models in terms of ear anatomy, inner ear morphology, and electrophysiological characteristics, as well as recent advancements in the development of distinct genetically modified porcine models of hearing loss. Additionally, we discuss the prospects, challenges, and recommendations regarding the use pig models in HHL research. Overall, this review provides insights and perspectives for future studies on HHL using porcine models.

Effect of 2.45 GHz Microwave Radiation on the Inner Ear: A Histopathological Study on 2.45 GHz Microwave Radiation and Cochlea.

BACKGROUND: The present study aims to determine the possible low dose-dependent adverse effects of 2.45 GHz microwave exposure and Wi-Fi frequency on the cochlea. METHODS: Twelve pregnant female rats (n=12) and their male newborns were exposed to Wi-Fi frequencies with varying electric field values of 0.6, 1.9, 5, 10 V/m, and 15 V/m during the 21-day gestation period and 45 days after birth, except for the control group. Auditory brainstem response testing was performed before exposure and sacrification. After removal of the cochlea, histopathological examination was conducted by immunohistochemistry methods using caspase (cysteine-aspartic proteases, cysteine aspartates, or cysteine-dependent aspartate-directed proteases)-3, -9, and terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL). Kruskal-Wallis and Wilcoxon tests and multivariate analysis of variance were used. RESULTS: Auditory brainstem response thresholds in postexposure tests increased statistically significantly at 5 V/m and above doses. When the number of apoptotic cells was compared in immunohistochemistry examination, significant differences were found at 10 V/m and 15 V/m doses (F(5,15)=23.203, P=.001; Pillai's trace=1.912, η2=0.637). As the magnitude of the electric field increased, all histopathological indicators of apoptosis increased. The most significant effect was noted on caspase-9 staining (η2 c9=0.996), followed by caspase-3 (η2 c3=0.991), and TUNEL staining (η2 t=0.801). Caspase-3, caspase-9, and TUNEL-stained cell densities increased directly by increasing the electric field and power values. CONCLUSION: Apoptosis and immune activity in the cochlea depend on the electric field and power value. Even at low doses, the electromagnetic field in Wi-Fi frequency damages the inner ear and causes apoptosis.

Making Recommendations for an Evaluation and Treatment Algorithm for Patients with Ear Fullness and No Objective Abnormalities.

OBJECTIVE: To make recommendations for evaluation, approach to counseling and treatment for patients who present with ear fullness without abnormalities on otomicroscopic examination, standard audiometric studies, or imaging results. METHODS: Retrospective chart review of adult patients in a tertiary referral center presenting with ear fullness and/or otalgia without external, middle, and/or inner ear pathologies. Data collected include demographics (age and gender), laterality and duration of symptoms, co-morbid conditions and final diagnoses of temporomandibular joint (TMJ) dysfunction, intermittent Eustachian tube dysfunction (iETD), migraine disorder, and anxiety. RESULTS: In the span of 8 years of a single neurotologist's practice, 964 patients presented with ear fullness. After excluding all instances where external, middle, and inner ear disorders were identified and where audiometric and radiologic findings were abnormal, 263 patients had ear fullness and no objective causes. Women were more likely than men to complain of ear fullness and/or otalgia and were also more likely to present with no objective abnormalities ( p < 0.05). Patients who reported isolated ear fullness were more likely to be diagnosed with iETD, whereas patients who reported pain were more likely to be diagnosed with TMJ dysfunction (TMJD). Fourteen patients (5.3%) had completely unexplained sensation of ear fullness. CONCLUSIONS: There were 94.7% of the patients presenting with unexplained ear fullness were diagnosed as having a possible contribution of TMJ dysfunction, IETD, migraine disorder, anxiety, or a combination of these conditions to their symptomatology. Directing treatments toward these diagnoses may alleviate symptoms of ear fullness or, if unsuccessful, provide an avenue for counseling in the framework of functional neurologic disorders.

A novel radiological software prototype for automatically detecting the inner ear and classifying normal from malformed anatomy.

BACKGROUND: To develop an effective radiological software prototype that could read Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) files, crop the inner ear automatically based on head computed tomography (CT), and classify normal and inner ear malformation (IEM). METHODS: A retrospective analysis was conducted on 2053 patients from 3 hospitals. We extracted 1200 inner ear CTs for importing, cropping, and training, testing, and validating an artificial intelligence (AI) model. Automated cropping algorithms based on CTs were developed to precisely isolate the inner ear volume. Additionally, a simple graphical user interface (GUI) was implemented for user interaction. Using cropped CTs as input, a deep learning convolutional neural network (DL CNN) with 5-fold cross-validation was used to classify inner ear anatomy as normal or abnormal. Five specific IEM types (cochlear hypoplasia, ossification, incomplete partition types I and III, and common cavity) were included, with data equally distributed between classes. Both the cropping tool and the AI model were extensively validated. RESULTS: The newly developed DICOM viewer/software successfully achieved its objectives: reading CT files, automatically cropping inner ear volumes, and classifying them as normal or malformed. The cropping tool demonstrated an average accuracy of 92.25%. The DL CNN model achieved an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.86 (95% confidence interval: 0.81-0.91). Performance metrics for the AI model were: accuracy (0.812), precision (0.791), recall (0.8), and F1-score (0.766). CONCLUSION: This study successfully developed and validated a fully automated workflow for classifying normal versus abnormal inner ear anatomy using a combination of advanced image processing and deep learning techniques. The tool exhibited good diagnostic accuracy, suggesting its potential application in risk stratification. However, it is crucial to emphasize the need for supervision by qualified medical professionals when utilizing this tool for clinical decision-making.

Protocol for a multicentre randomised controlled trial of STeroid Administration Routes For Idiopathic Sudden sensorineural Hearing loss: The STARFISH trial.

Idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss (ISSNHL) is the rapid onset of reduced hearing due to loss of function of the inner ear or hearing nerve of unknown aetiology. Evidence supports improved hearing recovery with early steroid treatment, via oral, intravenous, intratympanic or a combination of routes. The STARFISH trial aims to identify the most clinically and cost-effective route of administration of steroids as first-line treatment for ISSNHL. STARFISH is a pragmatic, multicentre, assessor-blinded, three-arm intervention, superiority randomised controlled trial (1:1:1) with an internal pilot (ISRCTN10535105, IRAS 1004878). 525 participants with ISSNHL will be recruited from approximately 75 UK Ear, Nose and Throat units. STARFISH will recruit adults with sensorineural hearing loss averaging 30dBHL or greater across three contiguous frequencies (confirmed via pure tone audiogram), with onset over a ≤3-day period, within four weeks of randomisation. Participants will be randomised to 1) oral prednisolone 1mg/Kg/day up to 60mg/day for 7 days; 2) intratympanic dexamethasone: three intratympanic injections 3.3mg/ml or 3.8mg/ml spaced 7±2 days apart; or 3) combined oral and intratympanic steroids. The primary outcome will be absolute improvement in pure tone audiogram average at 12-weeks following randomisation (0.5, 1.0, 2.0 and 4.0kHz). Secondary outcomes at 6 and 12 weeks will include: Speech, Spatial and Qualities of hearing scale, high frequency pure tone average thresholds (4.0, 6.0 and 8.0kHz), Arthur Boothroyd speech test, Vestibular Rehabilitation Benefit Questionnaire, Tinnitus Functional Index, adverse events and optional weekly online speech and pure tone hearing tests. A health economic assessment will be performed, and presented in terms of incremental cost effectiveness ratios, and cost per quality-adjusted life-year. Primary analyses will be by intention-to-treat. Oral prednisolone will be the reference. For the primary outcome, the difference between group means and 97.5% confidence intervals at each time-point will be estimated via a repeated measures mixed-effects linear regression model.

Patterns of Signal Intensity in CISS MRI of the Inner Ear and Eye.

BACKGROUND: Constructive interference in steady state (CISS) is a gradient echo magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) pulse sequence that provides excellent contrast between cerebrospinal fluid and adjacent structures but is prone to banding artifacts due to magnetic field inhomogeneities. We aimed to characterize artifacts in the inner ear and eye. METHODS: In 30 patients (60 ears/eyes) undergoing CISS sequence MRI, nine low-signal intensity regions were identified in the inner ear and compared to temporal bone histopathology. The number and angle of bands across the eye were examined. RESULTS: In the cochlea, all ears had regions of low signal corresponding to anatomy (modiolus (all), spiral lamina (n = 59, 98.3%), and interscalar septa (n = 50, 83.3%)). In the labyrinth, the lateral semicircular canal crista (n = 42, 70%) and utricular macula (n = 47, 78.3%) were seen. Areas of low signal in the vestibule seen in all ears may represent the walls of the membranous utricle. Zero to three banding artifacts were seen in both eyes (right: 96.7%, mean 1.5; left: 93.3%, mean 1.3). CONCLUSION: Low signal regions in the inner ear on CISS sequences are common and have consistent patterns; most in the inner ear represent anatomy, appearing blurred due to partial volume averaging. Banding artifacts in the eye are more variable.

Deep reinforcement learning and convolutional autoencoders for anomaly detection of congenital inner ear malformations in clinical CT images.

Detection of abnormalities within the inner ear is a challenging task even for experienced clinicians. In this study, we propose an automated method for automatic abnormality detection to provide support for the diagnosis and clinical management of various otological disorders. We propose a framework for inner ear abnormality detection based on deep reinforcement learning for landmark detection which is trained uniquely in normative data. In our approach, we derive two abnormality measurements: Dimage and Uimage. The first measurement, Dimage, is based on the variability of the predicted configuration of a well-defined set of landmarks in a subspace formed by the point distribution model of the location of those landmarks in normative data. We create this subspace using Procrustes shape alignment and Principal Component Analysis projection. The second measurement, Uimage, represents the degree of hesitation of the agents when approaching the final location of the landmarks and is based on the distribution of the predicted Q-values of the model for the last ten states. Finally, we unify these measurements in a combined anomaly measurement called Cimage. We compare our method's performance with a 3D convolutional autoencoder technique for abnormality detection using the patch-based mean squared error between the original and the generated image as a basis for classifying abnormal versus normal anatomies. We compare both approaches and show that our method, based on deep reinforcement learning, shows better detection performance for abnormal anatomies on both an artificial and a real clinical CT dataset of various inner ear malformations with an increase of 11.2% of the area under the ROC curve. Our method also shows more robustness against the heterogeneous quality of the images in our dataset.

Inner Ear Organoids: Strengths and Limitations.

Inner ear organoids derived from differentiation of human pluripotent stem cells have recently gained momentum as tools to study inner ear development and developmental defects. An additional exciting aspect about this technology is represented by its translational potential, specifically, the use of organoids to validate therapeutics for hearing and balance restoration on human/patient-specific cells. This latter aspect will be briefly discussed here including opportunities and current limitations.

Cochlear aqueduct revisited: A histological study using human fetuses.

BACKGROUND AND AIM: The cochlear aqueduct (CA) connects between the perilymphatic space of the cochlea and the subarachnoid space in the posterior cranial fossa. The study aimed to examine 1) whether cavitation of the CA occurs on the subarachnoid side or the cochlear side and 2) the growth and/or degeneration of the CA and its concomitant vein. METHODS: We examined paraffin-embedded histological sections from human fetuses: 15 midterm fetuses (crown-rump length or CRL, 39-115 mm) and 12 near-term fetuses (CRL, 225-328 mm). RESULTS: A linear mesenchymal condensation, i.e., a likely candidate of the CA anlage, was observed without the accompanying vein at 9-10 weeks. The vein appeared until 15 weeks, but it was sometimes distant from the CA. At 10-12 weeks, the subarachnoid space (or the epidural space) near the glossopharyngeal nerve rapidly protruded into the CA anlage and reached the scala tympani, in which cavitation was gradually on-going but without epithelial lining. However, CA cavitation did not to occur in the anlage. At the opening to the scala, the epithelial-like lining of the CA lost its meningeal structure. At near-term, the CA was often narrowed and obliterated. CONCLUSION: The CA develops from meningeal tissues when the cavitation of the scala begins. The latter cavitation seemed to reduce tissue stiffness leading, to meningeal protrusion. The so-called anlage of CA might be a phylogenetic remnant of the glossopharyngeal nerve branch. A course of cochlear veins appears to be determined by a rule different from the CA development.

Noise Stress Abrogates Structure-Specific Endonucleases within the Mammalian Inner Ear.

Nucleotide excision repair (NER) is a multistep biochemical process that maintains the integrity of the genome. Unlike other mechanisms that maintain genomic integrity, NER is distinguished by two irreversible nucleolytic events that are executed by the xeroderma pigmentosum group G (XPG) and xeroderma pigmentosum group F (XPF) structure-specific endonucleases. Beyond nucleolysis, XPG and XPF regulate the overall efficiency of NER through various protein-protein interactions. The current experiments evaluated whether an environmental stressor could negatively affect the expression of Xpg (Ercc5: excision repair cross-complementing 5) or Xpf (Ercc4: excision repair cross-complementing 4) in the mammalian cochlea. Ubiquitous background noise was used as an environmental stressor. Gene expression levels for Xpg and Xpf were quantified from the cochlear neurosensory epithelium after noise exposure. Further, nonlinear cochlear signal processing was investigated as a functional consequence of changes in endonuclease expression levels. Exposure to stressful background noise abrogated the expression of both Xpg and Xpf, and these effects were associated with pathological nonlinear signal processing from receptor cells within the mammalian inner ear. Given that exposure to environmental sounds (noise, music, etc.) is ubiquitous in daily life, sound-induced limitations to structure-specific endonucleases might represent an overlooked genomic threat.

Transgenic Tg(Kcnj10-ZsGreen) fluorescent reporter mice allow visualization of intermediate cells in the stria vascularis.

The stria vascularis (SV) is a stratified epithelium in the lateral wall of the mammalian cochlea, responsible for both endolymphatic ion homeostasis and generation of the endocochlear potential (EP) critical for normal hearing. The SV has three layers consisting predominantly of basal, intermediate, and marginal cells. Intermediate and marginal cells form an intricate interdigitated network of cell projections making discrimination of the cells challenging. To enable intermediate cell visualization, we engineered by BAC transgenesis, reporter mouse lines expressing ZsGreen fluorescent protein under the control of Kcnj10 promoter and regulatory sequences. Kcnj10 encodes KCNJ10 protein (also known as Kir4.1 or Kir1.2), an ATP-sensitive inwardly-rectifying potassium channel critical to EP generation, highly expressed in SV intermediate cells. In these transgenic mice, ZsGreen fluorescence mimics Kcnj10 endogenous expression in the cochlea and was detected in the intermediate cells of the SV, in the inner phalangeal cells, Hensen's, Deiters' and pillar cells, in a subset of spiral ganglion neurons, and in glial cells. We show that expression of the transgene in hemizygous mice does not alter auditory function, nor EP. These transgenic Tg(Kcnj10-ZsGreen) mice allow live and fixed tissue visualization of ZsGreen-expressing intermediate cells and will facilitate future studies of stria vascularis cell function.

Variability in Manual Segmentation of Temporal Bone Structures in Cone Beam CT Images.

PURPOSE: Manual segmentation of anatomical structures is the accepted "gold standard" for labeling structures in clinical images. However, the variability in manual segmentation of temporal bone structures in CBCT images of the temporal bone has not been systematically evaluated using multiple reviewers. Therefore, we evaluated the intravariability and intervariability of manual segmentation of inner ear structures in CBCT images of the temporal bone. METHODS: Preoperative CBCTs scans of the inner ear were obtained from 10 patients who had undergone cochlear implant surgery. The cochlea, facial nerve, chorda tympani, mid-modiolar (MM) axis, and round window (RW) were manually segmented by five reviewers in two separate sessions that were at least 1 month apart. Interreviewer and intrareviewer variabilities were assessed using the Dice coefficient (DICE), volume similarity, mean Hausdorff Distance metrics, and visual review. RESULTS: Manual segmentation of the cochlea was the most consistent within and across reviewers with a mean DICE of 0.91 (SD = 0.02) and 0.89 (SD = 0.01) respectively, followed by the facial nerve with a mean DICE of 0.83 (SD = 0.02) and 0.80 (SD = 0.03), respectively. The chorda tympani had the greatest amount of reviewer variability due to its thin size, and the location of the centroid of the RW and the MM axis were also quite variable between and within reviewers. CONCLUSIONS: We observed significant variability in manual segmentation of some of the temporal bone structures across reviewers. This variability needs to be considered when interpreting the results in studies using one manual reviewer.